===== From klynn@uswest.net: Cool animation. I think I'd like to have had a tight shot of one of the minnows. Maybe do one with more detail, then lower the detail in later frames? ===== From Martin.Magnusson.7121@student.uu.se: This is very beatiful. I love the way the "fish" move, their silvery appearance and the blue shades, but I can't give a very high concept score, I'm afraid. I'd like to see something more, maybe some more suttoundings, maybe some more individuality on the fish. ===== From vansickl@erols.com: The bodies of the "fish" in the rear tend to flip around a lot. ===== From edmichalski@hotmail.com: A few closeups on the minnows would be nice. ===== From gregj56590@aol.com: An extremely beautiful symphony of moving creatures. Artistically appealing and a great technical accomplishment. Your algorithm, however, needs some tweaking. Minnows are not ever going to instantaneously change their position, as yours appear to be doing in the jerky side to side motion. Record the "previous velocity" of each fish and average the "new calculated velocity" with it. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Impressive movement, very realistic. Animation doesn't tell much of a story, though. ===== From file: Good Idea. But I don't think fishes really behave like that... I love that effect when they show it in Documentaries - the glow and the incredible perfection of their movements is spectacular. I would like to see the next version of this movie - Watch some more National Geographic for ideas ;-) Notable for originality