===== From agage@csee.usf.edu: Nicely done...perhaps time I play with Blender again. The bubbles were particularly effective. The glass was too transparent, though -- either needing some refraction, or perhaps caustics (which Blender might not do well). ===== From cnichol@magma.ca: I really liked the beer. The bubbles and the pouring were very well done. ===== From manorton@jps.net: Texture on bar and floor. Should have used a image map. ===== From dlauer@optonline.net: In found the way transparent glasses, and "fluid" wood grain a little annoying. The beer looks good though! ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: I liked the attention to detail the textures were nice. Although The glasses were a bit too transparent....Good camera angles. nice smooth animation.... the concept was lacking.... perhaps the robot needed a bit of something... maybe a personality or something a bit more but other than that a great animation ... very nice ===== From ldnbruce@flash.net: Too dark. The glasses were too transparent, there shape got lost through much of the film. The bar texture and floor texture should have contrasted they blended together and confused the perspective during the camera move. ===== From Michael@nmtrix.com: Nice ambiance, good subject indeed. Nice modelling. Shame you didn't use any refractions when you view the droid through the glass. ===== From chipr@niestu.com: Beautiful execpt for the non-shiny glasses. Some specular reflections at least would have been nice. Beer was okay, though a bit static-looking. ===== From mark.wagner17@gte.net: Nice job modeling the robot arm. The animated texture of the wood detracts from the animation by drawing the viewer's eye away from the robot. The head on the beer should mushroom out and spill over the edges of the glass. ===== From file: Notable for originality ===== From file: The glasses without shiny spts dont't really look like glasses. But the beer looks great (yum). ===== From file: I liked the arm and it's movement, but the glasses were too transparent. The wood texture seemed to have a life of it's own. Notable for modelling