===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: The concept was good. I thought the camera angles and sense of movement could have been better. Fun idea though a bit crude. ===== From pdolan@jps.net: I like the surprising ending. The environment needs a lot of work - a simple red plain doesn't work. I like the flipped coin, the animation and texturing was well done, but where'd it come from? What did the sign mean? ===== From Alain.Culos@bigfoot.com: You said it yourself : RENDERER USED: pure 3dsmax scanline renderer I understand the competition is supposed to be raytracing, not scanline. I liked the lotery bit ... yes that's really part of life, isn't it ? ===== From neilryan@mtco.com: Nice camera work. I think the overall movement could have been a lot better. The coin was well done. ===== From file: Isn't this supposed to be the IRay-TracingC