===== From AzChip@aol.com: Excellent work. The pacing is very good, the punchline is well delivered. Very good entry. ===== From philip.chan@home.com: A pretty good animation overall. The explosion didn't have enough punch too it (the fireball was a little too small), but having done an explosion myself in my animation, I can understand why it's hard to do a good explosion. The sun at the end looks great! ===== From mbcx7tdy@stud.man.ac.uk: I definitely agree that the IRTC need to look at updating the codec requirements. Quite a few free tools exist for MPEG-2 now. ===== From boomerkuwanger@aol.com: There were some really nice textures, such as the moon and the starship. However, the explosion and starscape looked kind of silly. Actually, the explosion brought back nostalgia from late 80's 3D computer games (anyone remember Carrier Command? -- heh heh ) ===== From socrates1999@yahoo.com: Interesting animation. ===== From lou_bruce@yahoo.com: The soundtrack didn't have to be that crude. The story wasn't there. The punchline? wasn't funny.