=====
From brendanlemke@canada.com:
I liked your idea very much.  It's a great blend of fairly simple motions in a
clever sequence.  Some extra work on textures and camera movement would have
pushed your mark from me up near the top.  As it is, I still rated you very
well.
=====
From tim_cutho@smileyface.com:

You say:
note(i did not use any
motion editing 
program to slow down the speed ,everything is 1000ure rendered animation).

But slowing down animation has been a feature of max since version 1. . .

Wierd. . .
=====
From bill@apocalypse.org:
nice colors and good modeling on the objects
it seems a little short, I would have like more going on and more camera
movement or 'shots'.

=====
From ian.print@ntlworld.com:
Different idea, though somewhat odd. Not much of a story to it. Textures could
have been a bit better. The drop at the start when it falls seems to wobble
about - or is it the camera that moves? Looks wrong to me. Could do with a
better view of what the spring was doing - I assume it switches on the fan, but
it is obscured by the camera angle.

=====
From thomas_4d@hotmail.com:
sorry but i used max before i switched to inspire3d
and max can do so much more then this very plain for the tools that you had to
use :(



=====
From lou_bruce@yahoo.com:
 The first drop and the separation were excellent.
However your spring release mechanism doen't make any sense (it wouldn't work
like that in the real world). Then the prop is way too slow to generate any
breeze even in slow motion. So it doesn't make sense for the sail to move
nearly as fast as it does.
 The balls dropping and bouncing was very good.