===== From gsingelm@t-online.de: almost nothing changes in this picture. the raindrops are ok (probably hard to do in pov?) the candle is ok ===== From ma.al@anthrosphinx.de: I really liked the drops and the way they run down the glass pane. As for the transformation of good weather to rain - i did only see the rain, but this could be some problem with my MPEG playback. ===== From philip.chan@home.com: The candle flame and the candle's reflection are nice effects. However, the lighting effect for the flickering of the candle doesn't look quite right. It probably would have look better if it was quicker. It also would have been nice if the candle shrunk during the scene. Another nice effect would have been to have lightening. The cloud effect could also have been more realistic. On the positive side, the trees look nice, and the texturing for the scene is good. ===== From zach@brewstergeisz.cjb.net: Not sure how close this is to "transformation"... but a good interpretation nonetheless. I liked the clouds rolling overhead. ===== From evilsnack@hotmail.com: Not much happens. There are regular sudden leaps in the light level, which is not natural-looking. ===== From dearmad@sapere.com: I like the idea... but it needed something more. Though you placed quite high in my vote.