===== Lovely piece! Nice job on the lasers, flames, and that billowing black smoke. ===== I especially liked your landscape. ===== Very nicely executed. Good placement of all objects in the scene, and impressive fire halos. ===== Excelent picture ===== excellent atmosphere and good choice of colors! ===== You can use multiple halos with different color maps in on container object - as long as they are not attenuating halos. Emitting, glowing, and dust are all OK. You could have the smoke as attenuating and the fire as emitting all in the same container, each with different color maps. ===== Nice composition. Lots of action without over-crowding the scene. ===== You 've made some really nice explosions there. ===== nice, the tanks could use some improvement, and the turrets just look too cartoonish ===== This is the only picture i've viewed that i want to see the source for. Very nice use of halos. ===== Very well done smoke and flames. The details on the laser cannon are a nice touch ===== I like it a whole lot. Great effects. I'm amazed at the quality of the smoke and the fire. ===== Very nice image. The landscape and special effects are really good. ===== Laser beams are not made from some kind of liquid and they are NEVER pink ! Apart from that, I like the image. And yes, I think the fire and smoke are pretty good . ===== Nice image. Yes, I like the fire, very well done. Good landscape, too, not as cheezy as most. ===== I love that flaming ship! ===== The laser-impact halo is beautiful! :-) ===== Excellent use of halos! I like that very much. This image could almost be used as a good demo of how to use halos. One minor criticism: the green alien ships look too artificial. I don't know how to describe my feeling about these ships, but I think they would look better if there were more mechanical parts visible or if their surface was less polished (a light bumpmap or texture would probably help to give them some grainy effect which looks more realistic). Anyway, I like this scene very much. Maybe you could also add a few broken parts flying off the ship which just crashed. ===== Splendid image. This guy can sure make good fire. Dramatic skies and beautiful mountains ===== Very nice use of halos. ===== I like the smoke ===== nuf said ===== Very nice halo effects! ===== The flames and smoke do look good. Nice job. ===== I really like the way you did your lasers, especially the one in the foreground hitting the ship ! ===== I like the color scheme for the background and landscape it lends well to the picture. I would almost say things are a little to cluttered. ===== The flame and smoke stuff is top notch. I'm going to be sure to look at your source (assuming it's here!) to see how you did some of this. Some of it is a little too...cartoony. Tracks in the sand are a real nice touch. Sun light source cast harder shadows than it should, though that's real time-consuming to fix (render time). ===== too much action... ===== Cool - a fighting scene that looks bright and cheerful! ===== Nice quality ===== Nicely detailed scene, good use of halo. Tanks were a bit boxy.