=====
Starships look like toys.  Each one is the same size; very unrealistic.
Moonscape colors could have been better chosen.  Overall "toyish" look to the
scene.  Perspective tries to cover the entire battle, but ends up distancing
the viewer; first impression is of a drawing or painting.
=====
I think the main feature of this picture is the battle, not the colony getting
blasted.  Well done otherwise

=====

Enterprise shows off!!!
=====
I find this dull.


=====
The mountains could be better.

=====

The fighters are too small, and they resemble constitution class Federation
shipps, not fighters
Generally, just not all that interesting
=====
Star Trek RULES also!


=====
Texture on the hills is way too contrived.

=====
Much too much JPEG compression.

=====
The stripey hills were distracting.