===== Very nice job ===== A little dull. ===== Interesting idea. I like the lighting (especially the ships' spots), and the big japanese art adds a nice touch. ===== At first I thought those slightly brighter points showing up best on the city floor were raindrops, but eventually figured out that they were ONLY on the floor, thus must be peoples. ===== Very bladerunnerish. ===== I Love the lighting in this one. I think the city needs a little more detail in this picture though. Maybe if the streets had a little more detail or you could see a person on a balcony on one of the larger buildings or something. ===== Nice atmospherics. Pretty good buildings, but the lights are too regular. Howabout using rand() and a ternary operator (?:) to turn the lights on/off? ===== I think more randomness on the lights in the buildings would add a lot of realism ===== Very suggestive of Blade Runner--nice effect. Why do the people glow? The large signature was distracting. ===== There may be too much ground space here. How about a few foreground buildings to hide it?