===== Good job Harry, but the main ship seems to be slightly above the ground. ANd the shadows under the ship dont look that real. But GREAT MODELS! ===== An excellent eye for detail- very stunning! It would be good to see more images of this very high quality! ===== Good use of volumetrics ===== Stormtroopers are way too stiff, and they cast no shadows. ===== The stormtroopers are quite nice. ===== I really am getting tired of star wars entries. ===== Even though the models aren't yours, you've done a good job with them. ===== Stormtroopers are rather stiff looking. ===== Another technically excellent Star Wars image. ===== Seems to be a bit out of scale ===== Nice depth and scale BUT ~ hasn't Star Wars been done enough? ===== Obsessive attention to detail, but 3DStudio gets trampled on by POVRay when it gets to actual output. Sorry I didn't say that very well. ===== soldiers are a bit stiff ===== Copy paste, copy paste. Its all over. ===== Why are all the stormtroopers just standing at attention? ===== goooooood but originality is not there ===== Nice ===== Awesome! ===== I'm not a starwars fan, but this looks pretty cool. Who made the models? ===== The hands on the storm troopers could use some work. ===== I like this guys work I just wish he would have picked a different topic within the theme! ===== Truly amaze that author has such experiences of modeling which can craet great detail of models. However, I was the one who visited author's homepage a while ago, and he has a collection of those awesome models from star wars. I didn't give high enough score on concept, because star wars was not created by him and it is an idea people has been reuse for many years. Similar to Star Trek, there is nothing new we expect to see from this picture. I hope author can come up someting by himself. Of course, the way he is modeling could be very excellent skill and wish he will have future production with his own idea. :) ===== Stormtroops are too identical and regular--there should be a little variation ===== Harry, you've done the rendering community a great service by making all those Star Wars models, and posting them on the net. However, you did the competition no favors by entering *nine* images, all with stock models, all rendered with a high-priced commercial renderer. I gave you high marks for artistic merit, but low ones for tech and originality. All of your images were glossy but a bit sterile; this one in particular worked well since stiffness is an asset in a military formation! The lamp looked a little weird. too. I know a lot of people have already chastised you for submitting so many images, and I'm just adding my voice to theirs. I hope you enter in the future, but next time, just one image on a particular theme, okay? ===== Clearly YOU RULE! when it comes to star wars models! Sadly there are just too many space ship battles and such in the contest (many done with your models) to give high marks for originality. Notable for modelling