=====
More great models, but there was not a suficiant amount of distance ques to give
full depth of field.  3DMAX just may not be able to handel this as well as
PovRay but again.  EXELENT MODELS


=====
Where are the object's textures?

=====
The detail is nice... but the textures are flat.

=====

i don't like it when people just do one thing with such little imagination
you should do more than just put ptremade models on a background that
you used vista pro for.
=====
Not only does your background clash, but your figures look very un-lifelike.


=====
Good work on the models, but they need some work to be more realistically
posed.

=====
Stormtroopers still look like action figures.

=====

I could suggest one improvement that I think would make a large amount of
difference.
As this .jpg was rather slowly downloading over my 14.4 line, I kept expecting
to see the legs of the walkers rest on some sort of hillcrest. The background
looked like such a great patchy-forest type slope off in the distance, to see
that same surface under the walkers' feet throws off all sense of scale.
Also, since when do stormtroopers amble among the legs of walkers, weaponless
and apparently chatting to their buddies? :)

=====
That light gray texture is a bit flat

=====
Please just send one or two of the best of your works, unless they are
SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENT.

=====

Why does he spoil pictures as good as these by naming them with his initials!
Again POVRay runs rings round 3DS when it comes to looks.
=====
Star wars will not win it for you.

=====
Didn't I see stormtroopers in the last pic?

=====
Very nice stormtroopers.
With an area light, the image would have been even better.

=====
perfection in realisation

=====


How about a gun for the troopers?
=====
Only voting on one of your pictures.

=====
I strongly suspect that the mesh objects are not your own. I have seen them
elsewhere



=====
Vista PRO is a well made program which give author power to creat the
background.
However, it is very easy to creat this picture, since author already have a
collection of models in hand, and the mountain which was created by Vista PRO
was a easy job might not even take more than half hour to do so.  
That is the reason I grade down on the "Technical Merit" section.
=====
Too little texture or detail. The image seems flat and lifeless, and the
lighting of the Vista Pro seen is too different from the characters' lighting.
This makes them fit awkwardly in the scene.


=====
Awkward poses.