=====
Very nice image - feels cold yet moody at the same time.

=====


Wow, amazing!!!!!
=====
Coolest scene ever!

=====


Looks pretty cool Jon.  Don't deduct points on my originality.
=====
Great teamwork

=====
Definitely one of the best entries this competition has seen.


=====
Nice idea, very artistic. The purple clouds are cool, as is the central rose.
The overall layout is a bit crowded, though, and many details are so small
that they are lost in noise. And the blue chalice base is intersecting the
rail - looks odd. This image would look much better in about 4000x3000
resolution...

=====
bit  more AA, and texturing...., nice composition tho

=====
The image is very nice.   But the triangular holes at the foreground are too
pixellated.

=====
Very good. Very detailed.
Bravo!


=====
Very Nice.  I like the Wine glass detail.

=====
Great job!

=====
The image really needs to be smoothed, probably only +a0.5, maybe even not
quite
that fine.  The aliasing really detracts from what is otherwise a very nice
image.  The chalice is really neat, though maybe some special lighting on it
would keep it from fading into the background (at the top anyway).

=====
Excellent image, subtle and beautifully colored.  I really love the fountains,
although they look frozen--maybe they were supposed to.  Some extra
anti-aliasing would have killed the few remaining jaggies, but would have
driven the render time way up, I'll bet.  Overall great job!


=====
Notable for originality