=====
From sroberts@learn.senecac.on.ca:
*VERY* nice scene - a real jaw-dropper on first viewing.  I did notice a couple
teeny details that could stand to be tweaked; the top of the candle is too
smooth, and when a candle melts at an angle like this it invariably gets a
blobby dribble of wax running down the side.  The canld eflame itself is too
narrow from side to side.  The lighting is spectacular; very atmospheric *G*. 
I think the only other thing you could try to acheive perfection would be to
slide the window open a little and put some very simple filmy white curtains
blowing just slightly in a breeze.  But maybe that would be gilding the lily. 
20-20-20 anyway.
=====
From m-kolb@uiuc.edu:
This image kicks ass.  : )
The candles could use a little help, but other than that, I've given your 
image the highest marks so far. Well done!
- Michael J. Kolb

=====
From cgallego@nordnet.fr:

Not so original, but very good ambience...
http://home.nordnet.fr/~cgallego

=====
From bill.marrs@pureatria.com:
This scene is similar to some of the others (window with sunlight, eyeglasses, 
bottles, etc...) - but it's done very well.  Very well done scene.

=====
From 93semeno@scar.utoronto.ca:
There is a certain atmosphere to this image. It really has a mood. I especially
like the beams of light coming from the window. Feels like someone is about to
get knocked off. :)

=====
From ucoakc00@mcl.ucsb.edu:
Amazing. All the objects I've grown to hate somehow work in this scene. Nice
job.


=====
From danclegg@uniserve.com:
How.. Misty..
=====
From rea@st-and.ac.uk:
A good all round image.   Watch your contrast with glass, and most especially
with atmosphere - the colours can get a bit flat.   Also, you probably want
your halos to be a bit fatter - the candles look almost like lit dynamite ;)

=====
From jmills@stic.net:
Nice lighting...nice

=====
From amarok@geocities.com:
Great pic! Just one thing - I think you should have used a higher ambient value
for the candle.

=====
From bsieker@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de:
Very atmospheric setting; great lighting! The wine bottle seems too reflective
and the wine a little bit too light, but the overall work is excellent!

=====
From uvasst00@mcl.ucsb.edu:
A little too dark.

=====
From no13@ozemail.com.au:
Excellent lighting !

=====
From ptdawson@voicenet.com:
I like all of the shadows, and the atmosphere - nice scene!

=====
From lpurple@netcom.com:
Very suave; you can almost hear French accordian music. 

=====
From dick@buckosoft.com:
very nice colors.  Great use of "dark".


From web_user@173-127-214.ipt.aol.com:
It was so dark, it was difficult to understand.


From web_user@p5-01.z03.glo.be:
Notable for composition, lighting


From web_user@tonyv.aztec.co.za:
Nice atmosphere. But the red (?) wine looks a bit insipid. Or is that port?
Notable for lighting