===== From MMandl@aol.com: Maybe this is an idea that should be gone with the win "dow" ===== From bill.marrs@pureatria.com: This scene brings tears to my eyes... ===== From 93semeno@scar.utoronto.ca: I wonder how this would fit into the "SCHOOL" topic? :) ===== From ansellaa@acc.wuacc.edu: Since this seat is just over the wing, shouldn't there be an emergency exit somewhere in view? BTW: if we opened the window, would these two guys get sucked out? ;-) (as pure abstract art though, I think Bill's _was_ better.) ===== From ucoakc00@mcl.ucsb.edu: Using his concept makes you rather un-origional. And there is still pleanty of room for detail ===== From danclegg@uniserve.com: He used Mr.WindowSeat's bad idea (looking out a plane window at nothing in particular) only with some modifications (the window's square, the wall has a obviously tiled seamy bump_map on it, there's some pixelized height_field/image_map on the ground.) It aparently took 1h 28m on a pro 200. Get this: "They say that truly great ideas never die. And this concept worked out so well for my brother admin last round (when the topic was "Flight") that, once I realized that it was equally applicable to "Glass", I couldn't resist. If next round's topic is "View From an Airplane" then perhaps someone else will capitalize on this timeless scene." -Author Equally applicable to "Glass"? Worked out so well for my brother? This idea is timeless? Oh! ,it was timeless! It never had it's time!!! BAHAHAH!! Go away Chip!!!!! Keep up the good work. NOT!! ===== From Matthew_L_Ziegler@hill-top.com: AGAIN!!!!!!!! ===== From pjones@powerup.com.au: I was going to give you a score of 20/20/20 - but I was overcome by a feeling of deja vu at the last minute and changed my mind :-) ===== From bsieker@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de: Wrong horizon, badly lit, unoriginal. ===== From lowellr@globaldialog.com: I am assuming this is a joke entry for the following reasons I think it is a little to close to Bill M entry to be counted as original work. It is a little (+++) too unfinished to be counted as your "best". Aside from an invisble window there is no glass/etc in the picture. If you want suggestions on the picture - email ===== From lpurple@netcom.com: It's a clever enough concept, but to pull it off, this scene needs more airplane stuff. Just one or two more windows, and a seat-back would greatly reinforce it. ===== From dick@buckosoft.com: Interesting camera angle. You should have embossed the manufacturer on the pull down panel ("Boeing", "POV" :) From web_user@tonyv.aztec.co.za: Oooops!