=====
From chipr@niestu.com:
More fish at school.  Cute concept, but the atmosphere was too thick, making
the fish indistinct.  Nice vegetation, good setting and composition.

=====
From mbrown@spry.com:
Could use randomness in the fishies. a little more work but adds to the realism

=====
From jsaxton@folio.com:
Image is quite faded. I really like the shark. The fish are too uniformly made.

=====
From bbowen@cswnet.com:
I'm very impressed with the seaweed in two ways: 
1) The arrangement of them in and around the boulders comes off very
natural.
2) The way you've "made do". I'm sure Sonya will be pleased that her trees
have a found a new use. :) Very creative actually.

Overall, a school of fish is just a school of fish, even if they are finishing
school ( perhaps for good! :D ) You were right, it wasn't as creative as you
might have originally thought, but I did bump up the "Concept" score for your
unique twist on the subject.

=====
From xeo@sprynet.com:
Anything. There, happy?
just kidding. cute fish. nice picture.

=====
From ucoakc00@mcl.ucsb.edu:
Cute, but the new graduates are a bit too rigid in their rows. Some small
differences in positions would make a large difference. Good overall.


=====
From amarok@geocities.com:
Perhaps custics would have looked good?

=====
From bill.marrs@pureatria.com:
Good attention to detail (shark, rocks, grass), spotlight is interesting...

=====
From tholal@bga.com:
The rocks and the seaweed look great but the spotlights seem to be coming out of
nowhere.

=====
From klynn@minn.net:

even better caustics than the other one
=====
From shipbrk@gate.net:
Nice use of atmosphere.  The texture on the fish is a little odd, though --
makes me think of Odo on Deep Space Nine.

=====
From sonya_roberts@geocities.com:
I like the atmospheric feel that the murkiness gives this image.  And of course
I like the
seaweed, too.  The fish still look an awful lot like Gumby though.

=====
From jlb36@cornell.edu:
The use of atmospherics is very well done.  The fish could use a differnt
texture though; when was the last time you saw a jade fish? <grin>
=====
From jaime@ctav.es:
Nice undersea plant.
Jaime (jaime@ctav.es)

=====
From ptdawson@voicenet.com:
Hey, it looks good! The fish could use a little random positioning, though.

=====
From peter@table76.demon.co.uk:
What's wrong with goofy fish?  They _work_ :-) !