===== From rotht@televar.com: Too bad you didn't model the dolphin yourself... ===== From gregj56590@aol.com: Nice concept. Caustics show up on sea floor more than dolphin: I'd expect opposite in real life. ===== From d97ta@efd.lth.se: too bad you didn't model the dolphin yourself... the dolphin skin is too plastic. it should have some more 'specular' highlights to make the skin look wet. You need more fog as well... it doesn't look like underwater (although the water and sand does) ===== From karl@pemail.net: The bubbles actually look ok. ===== From mmandl@aol.com: This image has such a sense o graceful movement. ===== From buck@cs.byu.edu: Great texture on the dolphin. I like the air-bubbles, too, and the caustics add some nice effects. It's pretty empty, though... Some more details around and in the background would be nice. ===== From jaime@ctav.es: Es el primer uso original que he visto de un modelo de delfin. Las burbujas dan perfectamente la sensacion de movimiento. Bien! ===== From djconnel@flash.net: This is perhaps the best underwater scene in the round. The rendering of the bubbles is excellent -- it makes the static image have a dynamic which few scenes this round achieve. Yet it needs more. Too much of the scene is featureless water. Nevertheless, it is quite good. ===== From fisher2@pobox.upenn.edu: Unfortunately, I had to take a lot of points off of the tech score since the dolphin is the central theme of the pic and wasn't your own model. Otherwise, this is a ver nice image. I especially liked the caustics and air bubbles. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Finally your signature is not too distracting, as it was in previous images. Great action. Dynamic. Nice appearance of caustic sunlight reflections on the floor. Excellent dolphin, too bad you didn't make it. Bubbles are well-placed, but seem fuzzy?