===== From sshaw@fas.harvard.edu: The modeling is simple, but I appreciated your interpretation of the theme. The books look a little small to me, compared with the size of the report card. ===== From rexx@sci.fi: The table might need a bit more stuff and maybe some texture for the wall to make the place look a bit more like home? ===== From trioker@wanadoo.fr: I always apreciate humour in ray tracing pictures. I think this fits the theme, and the flowers are very cute. Unfortunatly some others part of the scene needed some extra design. ===== From brendthess@aol.com: The secondary light to the right of the scene needs to be changed. The shadows on the left wall do not look right at all. The painting is.... odd. ===== From kistler@nevada.edu: I laughed when I saw it. How true for some of us. The premise carries it. ===== From mar@physics.usyd.edu.au: Hilarious! Obviously unbelievable. :-) ===== From johnson@pharmacy.arizona.edu: Good, though sparse idea, marred by bizarre lighting, the light perfctly parrallel to the desk top is wrong, as it makes shadows disconnected from their objects, and, barring using a laser as a light source, cannot happen in real life. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Good first effort. You might want to work on proportion: I've never seen a report card that is five times the size of a flower vase... ===== From jull43@ij.net: Report card or posterboard. Proportions are way off and the plant appears to have two shadows. ===== From sdevet@istar.ca: Topicality is a bit fuzzy... Plant is nice, but the scene as a whole is a bit sparse. ===== From file: NIcely modeled, but textures could use a lot of help. Is that a window or a picture?