===== From sshaw@fas.harvard.edu: It has been a couple of years since I saw this location, but when I saw the image I had two reactions in quick succession: that the buildings looked awfully similar, and then that they seemed to be in the blocks that I remember. You explained this in your text file, and I appreciate the attention to detail in setting up your city. ===== From rexx@sci.fi: Not too unbelievable ;) That could happen ;-> ===== From brendthess@aol.com: The fireball should be closer to the front of Mir (shockwave effects). ===== From nijman@nmtrix.com: Nice detail in the houses, but there appears to be no lightning from the burning MIR. The MIR is very bad visible. ===== From gregj56590@aol.com: Superb apartment complexes: I'm not too inspired by your archdetriumphe. And flames on Mir aren't that great. Flames just don't stop with a hard edge as in your image. ===== From jgoeson@msn.com: Wow!!! My favorite so far! BTW, I was going to ding you on the Concept points, because it's not unbelievable at all that Mir is going to make a big splash in someone's living room, but then you said that it's not predicted to hit France, so I let the score stand. Outstanding job! ===== From johnson@pharmacy.arizona.edu: Stunning amount of work! ===== From MMandl@aol.com: Nice buildings. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Incredible detail on the city buildings and arch. Great use of light sources and atmosphere. Only flaw is that the fireball around Mir is too sharpe-edged, oblong. ===== From clem@dhol.com: Interesting idea. An awful lot of work. Several very clever techniques. The fire could be a bit more realistic. The falling debris, at first, had me reaching for a dustrag. I thought my monitor was dirty! The cobbles work very well. Very impressive. ===== From sdevet@istar.ca: Hrm... about a month to go, and I'll be in Europe on the 11th. I'll keep my eyes peeled. :) Very nice, dynamic image. Town looks great. I don't know Paris, but I would have expected some higher buildings in there.. the debris tail from Mir looks a bit like an isolated patch of stars,a nd seems a bit disconcerting.. ===== From peter@table76.demon.co.uk: Wow; I especially like the houses, as I've been trying to make scripted houses for different styles of house. ===== From file: Nice modelling. The fire halo could use a little bit of work. ===== From file: Nice, nice, nice. Great light sourcing, the falling mir looks incredibly realistic.