=====
From jknepley@chisp.net:
The ground, sky, and water need work.  Characters are stiff.  I like the skyline.
=====
From loomsbury@yahoo.com:
The water looks wrong.  The sky would probably be better, were it a plane, and work on your sky texture.  The city is ok, but the road needs work.
=====
From pmccombs@hotmail.com:
Good job for no tools.  Sky and water need work.  Characters are pretty good for blob creations. The city takes backseat to the battle, though.

=====
From scarmig@ohmss.com:
Theme-wise it doesn't really say anything about the "city", but it is a good concept of the future.  The sky and clouds feel flat.  Very nice modelling on the characters!  The waves in the water seem out of proportion to the city and characters.

=====
From tony@j4tb.com:
A very cool looking city. Lots of variety in the buldings more than I've seen yet. Your people are also well rendered. The water waves are too big and the water is a little off color. The sky is ok but It looks like you used a sky sphere. I have found creating a cloud plane looks tons better. The castle seems a little blobby I would add a little more detail to it. 

=====
From whhale@nvl.army.mil:
Nice Image but I feel that the Battle detracts from the city

=====
From kantell@qup.com:
reminds me of the Myst worlds with you, the user, getting obliterated by a purple death ray.  :)
=====
From marlo.steed@uleth.ca:

I liked the new wave city in the background... the water looked pretty good too.  Not sure how the figures work into the concept.
=====
From karl@pemail.net:
Nice city shame about the fighters

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
I really like the city itself in this scene... in fact, I would 
have liked to have seen it given more prominence.  The 
shaping on the buildings is very imaginative.  I think the 
sky and water could use some work.

=====
From tonyv@iafrica.com:
The city link is tenuous and only seems to be a backdrop to the 'fight'.