=====
From kingofmycastle@gmx.net:
In my opinion he has missed the theme, but not completely.

=====
From tek@evilsuperbrain.com:
Nice concept :) I really like the rocks, very convincing.

=====
From htkra1d@hotmail.com:
Thats a really nice image! Everything looks amazingly real, and if you haven't
told me the cave was really a protein I would never have guessed it. (My award
for the best use of a protein ;-). Also, the shiny surfaces doesn't look too
good, as you said. It makes the atmosphere a little less waterish. It is a
great image however. High ratings on this one!
=====
From extrememarinerfan@home.com:
Excellent idea and theme!
=====
From PovRayGuy@aol.com:
Excellent!  Great use of organics and lighting!

=====
From djohnston@iname.com:
I like this image alot. The composition is great, and I love the camera angle.

=====
From jaimevives@mixmail.com:
Very good scene. The composition is amazing, very descriptive. Lighting and 
texturing are also great, and all the free models are used finely. But the best
is it's originality. Is hard to find something to critize... only that the water

is almost inperceptible: perhaps a bit of camera distortion would have helped.


=====
From a.vandekraats@student.utwente.nl:
Looks very realistic. Original concept.

=====
From ZenPsycho@yahoo.com:
your 3d collage of found objects is an interesting technique. I'm not sure
whether to be impressed, or disgusted. I guess I'm one of those people that
believes in making everything from scratch.  



=====
From delfeld@mailcity.com:
(Please see the 'additional' comments, as I do not have the time left to write
individual ones.)


=====
From file:
Nice job on the objects. I think, the lighting could have been made better - it
does look like a sunny day, instead of some underwater scene.
Notable for modelling