===== From elias@users.sourceforge.net: Artistic Merit: I like the sword, and also the effect of the green fog and the red glow in the back. Technical Merit: Not much details, and some places look polygonated. Concept, originality, interpretation of theme: Another floating sword. At least you provide some nice story to read :) ===== From fmurr@free.fr: Pretty good lighting atmosphere.If you place something in your image,it has to be seen otherwise no use to spend time on it don't you think so? Try Blender next time a very good free software(and a lot ===== From delfeld@mailcity.com: The repetition of forms works well. It is too static to maintain my interest, probably due to the lack of thematic interpretation and the balanced composition. A useful question to ask yourself: visually speaking, why did you place the stalagtites placed where they are? ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: The sword has a nice (if somewhat simple) shape to it. The water looks good too. I agree that the glow around the sword should be more turbulent. Nice fantasy feel here. ===== From file: great engraving, but the sword is more like a dagger, blade too short for such a pommel. The background is simplistic and unrelated to the story. (i thought the sword was in a tunnel, looks like some islands landscape to me). ===== From file: great engraving, but the sword is more like a dagger, blade too short for such a pommel. The background is simplistic and unrelated to the story. (i thought the sword was in a tunnel, looks like some islands landscape to me).