===== From fmurr@free.fr: Everything is fine,composition,lighting,textures. the hook with it's reflects is amazing. ===== From jesseh@softhome.net: Very nicely done Tinkerbell and the hook is quite convincing. One thing though, Tinkerbell's wings look like she nicked them from a passing butterfly... ;) ===== From delfeld@mailcity.com: At least you picked a different story to render than most. The composition is a little confusing. The shadows from the cage take over the shapes. Good work with textures and gestures. ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: Good work here. Nice use of strong lighting, and I like the glow of Tinkerbell's wings. The shaping on the hook and cage look good. The wood textures are nice, but I think the one on the barrels looks a little odd. Nice scene overall, though. ===== From davidbridge@msn.com: Great interpretation and a nice image ===== From file: good looking image, the wood textures could have more work, the hook looks right. Nonetheless i feel the main focus of the image is in some modelling from poser and other programs (campanilla) which have this models already created. Notable for lighting