===== From elias@users.sourceforge.net: Artistic Merit: The lighting, and the guardian, look quite nice. But something is striking me as odd..maybe the wall, or the water, i'm not sure. 12/20. Technical Merit: I like how that glowing is done. The wings of the creature looks very polygon-made. There's not that much else, so technical score: 8/20. Concept, originality, interpretation of theme: Nothing spectacular, but at least it's a guardian and not a sword, floating over the water. ===== From tony@awmcs.net: I am not sure how this relates to fantasy and mysticism but the star background is really cool. ===== From delfeld@mailcity.com: Mythical beings is not the limit of fantasy and/or mysticism. The image should be clipped so that everything in it is there for a reason. ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: Nice work on the figure and the lighting effects, although the glow around the figure seems somewhat regular. A more detailed background scene would have helped this scene a lot for me. ===== From file: mmmhh, not many things on the scene... ===== From r@203-79-95-74.apx0.paradise.net.nz: almost scary Notable for modelling, lighting