===== From philip.chan@home.com: Good job! The instrument panel seen in the cockpit of the nearest airplane is a nice addition to the scene. Considering the size of the explosions on the airplanes I would have created some debris flying around and a damaged aircraft, rather than using what appears to be an intact model of the airplane. ===== From lrwii@joplin.com: Every thing looks well made. The air is to crowded with planes, The bridge is out of place. Where does it lead to? ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: Nice smoke effects, and the landscape looks good (although the colors look a little odd in spots). I can't really figure out who is fighting who, though... to me it looks more like an aeriel free-for-all than two distinct sides coming together in battle. Nice scene overall, though. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Quite a dynamic scene. Good detail on the aircraft and smoke/fire effects. Seems to be a lack of shadows throughout the image. Is that a bridge in the lower right corner? If so, it must be huge, compared to the nearby mountains. It's up in the clouds! ===== From tm-ray@consistent.org: I really don't care for bitmapped backgrounds, particular ones which take up so much of the image.