===== From tom@tomandlu.co.uk: Nice concept, and some good modelling. The cloud could be better. ===== From matt@alledora.co.uk: Okay... wow. That's about all I have to say right now... ===== From johnkbradshaw@hotmail.com: Notable for originality ===== From staff@clickquicknow.com: Great work... this one would be good for this topic and even the next one. ===== From topher@csh.rit.edu: Wow, this looks great! This would have been very good in the next round as well! ===== From jjaguar@worldnet.att.net: I like the concept, nice work! The only thing I can really fault is the cloud. It doesn't fit in well and doesn't seem to have the same level of detail as the rest of the image. It needs more work, though I think it could be eliminated altogether and the snow can just be sort of spiraling up from the cup. ===== From henry@unforgettable.com: The cloud lets the picture down, more specifically (as you point out) the connection of the snow with the cloud. A superb idea. ===== From p_chan@shaw.ca: I like the concept for the scene. The objects in the scene look pretty good. As you mentioned, the snow seems to be missaligned with the cloud. I like how you've textured the cup so it looks like you can see the design on the front bleeding through to the interior. ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: A cute but good approach to the concept... I like it. The way the snow swirls looks good, although I agree it could be better integrated with the cloud. (The cloud, by the way, looks a little solid to me.) Still, very nice overall, and shows a good sense of imagination and creativity. ===== From kantell@qup.com: heh heh heh... I like this one. Go Dairy Queen!