=====
From tom@tomandlu.co.uk:
A very attractive image - scores high for artistic.

=====
From tek@evilsuperbrain.com:
Very nice modelling and textures, but the lighting looks out of place. It's obvious there are multiple light sources, and you don't really expect an 18th century room to have multiple coloured lights.

=====
From johnkbradshaw@hotmail.com:
The multiple shadows are unrealistic/annoying. Use area lights for soft shadows and shadowless lights for fill lights. Otherwise nice image.

=====
From topher@csh.rit.edu:
Great use of color. My only complaint is that the houses look a little bit too flat,
like their made of cardboard. But all in all, great use of lighting!

=====
From thomas_alun@lineone.net:
I don't think the multiple light sources work too well - the distinct,
coloured shadows are a bit distracting. I think you either need more
lights, closer together, or area-lights (if your software supports
them).

=====
From p_chan@shaw.ca:
I like the "black and white" feel of the image.  It's a 
really nice touch.  The detail on the objects is also very 
nice.  I personally don't like the effect created by the 
multiple light sources.  It looks rather awkward and 
unrealistic to me.

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
Nice scene.  Texturing on the walls is good and subtle, 
and the scrollwork on the fireplace screen looks good.  
The buildings look good, but a little simplistic compared 
to the room itself.  Lighting is interesting, although the 
shadows could be a little softer.  Good work overall.