===== From trothgard@citywidesoftware.com: I like how the picture is very busy, the one thing I didn't care for in this picture was the one lamppost in the front that blocked the piano, I think it could've been better without it there, IMHO. I love your use of textures, very well done ===== From cly@u.arizona.edu: great details, I love it. I do suggest that you have more smaller clouds at the horizon since you are looking far in the distance. It just look like the cloud is cut off ===== From pokorny@attglobal.net: My pick for the best image in this round. My only complaint for which I took a few tenths from technical merit is where the horizon meets the sky and the sky iteself where in meets the horizon. Some fog perhaps or given it is a dream some nice color gradient from the sea upward might have worked better. Still a great image. ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: Very nice...all the objects look great. The background seems a bit empty to me though. And the topic of dreaming doesn't really come through in the scene itself, at least for me.