===== From trothgard@citywidesoftware.com: I love the picture, it is nice and warm, the color choices were great. The models felt simplistic to me, except for the ivy. As for the topic, I couldn't see how this really fit into it. ===== From cly@u.arizona.edu: I'm not sure how this image relates to the topic. You will have to provide better input in your description. First off, the grass, looks to simple. I think you should have more. You sky is great, and the architecture looks good, but not sure how you made it. What renderer did you use ===== From robbert@mintec.ca: Not too sure how this fits with the theme really. The vines on the wall are nicely done. Nice warm lighting but the sky doesn't seem to match the lighting. Grass on the sides could be thicker. A lot of the surfaces feel a little flat. Good work though, keep it up. ===== From pokorny@attglobal.net: The vine work is nice and the wall looks good but is perhaps more like todays concrete block walls when painted. Scored especially low because I could not see a strong link to the dreaming topic. ===== From lrwii@joplin.com: No documentation. I'd say off topic. ===== From r@www-cacheb.soton.ac.uk: a little off topid? a description of why it's not might have been nice...