===== From fcueto@rice.edu: no description, no points. ===== From dbn_3@yahoo.com: The sky is the weakest part. It looks very strange. The next thing to change is the lighting. There are no shadows anywhere! But I do like the rocks and the plant itself. ===== From bertram.henze@t-online.de: Looks much like the Burren, a flat rocky region in the county Clare of Ireland, with flowers growing in the grooves between big brimstone slabs. ===== From jyrehby@hotmail.com: Pros: Good composition, interesting point of view, good interpretation of the topic. The sky is beautiful. Cons: The black rock in the background looks weirdly out of place. The stone texture could be use more subtle variations, the plant looks somewhat flat and lacking contrast. In fact, the whole scene seems washed out. Maybe it's a gamma issue and it looks perfect on your monitor? Hard to tell, since you provided no information in the text file.