===== From reinhard.pieper@web.de: Very nice camera work! Naturalistic style is always a challenge! Maybe some white ash on the wood? Very nice image! ===== From enrique.sahagun@uam.es: I work too with pov ray and I'm fascinated with fire, actually with the whole image. Congratulations. ===== From : This could so easily be a photograph, the quality is incredibly good. My overall favourite this round! ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Nice concept. Nice image. The water and stone is particularly impressive - the texture and nature look are great. ===== From tomvw87@hotmail.com: This is amazing, this image has a great deal of realism, and really appeals to me! I like it! ===== From diegocg@quipo.it: Good work, specially on water! I think fire can be improved a bit, to reach best result. ===== From file: Fantastic, faultless... Easily the best image in the round. The water/waves meeting the shore are amazing! Notable for composition, originality, modelling, lighting ===== From file: Very cool... yet hot; a solid effort... yet fluid. Nice work. Notable for composition, originality, textures ===== From file: Notable for modelling ===== From file: nice fire