===== From reinhard.pieper@web.de: A little bit too much focal blur for my taste. Rotating the trees could help to individualize them. ===== From tek@evilsuperbrain.com: Very pretty image, good use of focal blur. Though the high camera position and excessive blur make it look like we're looking at a very small scene, like a model not real trees. ===== From enrique.sahagun@uam.es: A very beautifull image. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: The conept was good and I found the image interesting. However, it would have improved by greater realism. The other thing is the depth of field doesn't really enhance this particular image - perhaps if you had a larger central obect that was in focus, it might have worked. ===== From tomvw87@hotmail.com: The concept of the contrast between winter and summer-scapes is good, but it looks so flat, like it doesn't have any dimension. ===== From xtpy@hotmail.com: Although the blur was intended to achieve a dream-like effect, I think that it may have been over done. Possibly there could be another way to acheive the dream atmoshpere. (possibly with fogor lighting?) Just my personal opinion though.