===== From reinhard.pieper@web.de: The glasses and liquids could have been a little bit more realistic for my taste. Without any thickness I couldn's tell it were glasses. Nice composition. ===== From aargri@gmail.com: I love the look of this scene, for reasons I cannot place. The only thing that I don't like is the dark upper-left corner. It breaks the symmetric unsymmetry of the piece. ===== From tek@evilsuperbrain.com: It looks like your empty glasses are solid cylinders of glass, so they don't look like glasses. You need to do a difference with a smaller cylinder to make the empty space inside the glass. Also, your full glasses are only half-full, so not really opposites. Still, it's a fairly interesting idea. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: The concept is good but at first glance I didn't see empty and full, I saw transparent and color. The glasses don't look empty, they look solid to me. I think the texture of glass is the problem. I addition the glasses needed more thickness to them - they look paper thin. ===== From tomvw87@hotmail.com: It looks good, but i don't really understand the concept of it? ===== From file: Notable for lighting