===== From zekaric@yahoo.ca: In my opinion, the best of the competition this round. Well done! ===== From ian_c_thornton@hotmail.com: Superb image (as I already said on the POV forum). Only minor niggles are ... 1. The lava flows look a little too consistent and sharp 2. The outline of the smoke is too blurred 3. The image definitely would have benefitted from some anti-aliasing. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Nice concept, nice model, nice rendering. ===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: Great work, your bosses should have paid you double time ;-) Easily my favourite image of this round, the under water part looks much better than the early WIPs I saw and the smoke is great, already grabbed the source.. Thanks. ===== From jgrimbert@free.fr: Wonderful smokes! More ice in the water would have help. Is it a boat on the left or what ? ===== From file: Cool smoke. Contrast on the lower part of the vulcanoe seems to be too harsh, like on the moon. Notable for composition