===== From zekaric@yahoo.ca: The crackle on the ice seems unnecessary and brings down the image. The sky seems to have a bit of a plasma pattern in it that's noticeable. Good image otherwise. ===== From tek@evilsuperbrain.com: nice colours, the ice in the foreground looks a bit unrealistic though. ===== From ian_c_thornton@hotmail.com: Incredible sky and the snow looks good too. The way the snow hangs off the branches is well-realised. Only criticisms are the blurry details on the snow/ice ... the cracks look too regular and soft and where the shore meets the lake is also too soft. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: A stunning image. I loved the reflection on the lake which created a nice balance to the image. The snow and ice were realistic and the tree provided a nice backdrop. Great rendering, one of my favorites. ===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: Nice colours, the snow on the tree's doesn't look right but it is a nicely composed scene. ===== From jgrimbert@free.fr: Nice landscape. ===== From fcueto@rice.edu: Like it very much. The colors are very pleasing.