===== From zekaric@yahoo.ca: As far as the candles of this round go, this one isn't all that bad. The room it's in reminds me of those sound dissipation rooms and sort of odd why a candle would be here. But anyhoo, good work. ===== From ian_c_thornton@hotmail.com: The slush is spot-on, as is the flame. The ice crystals look way too dirty and solid though (there's not enough reflection/refraction going on to make these realistic). Overall I like it though. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: This is an interesting image and has a certain appeal. I like all the crystals. I liked the shape of the candle and it looks quite realistic. ===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: The flame and candle look good, I agree that the ice crystals could do with some more work on the texture, also I am not too keen on the floor. You picked a tough round for your first entry as it was not easy to think of what to do for this round. Don't give up after one attempt.. ===== From jgrimbert@free.fr: A bit too lonely.