=====
From zekaric@yahoo.ca:
This is a strange one.  It's nicely done but a bit of a stretch on the F&I theme
even though the elements are there.  The other symbolism in the image may make
it fit better with the theme of the next round "music" as it seems more
prevalent than the F&I.

=====
From tek@evilsuperbrain.com:
What you have there is a piano tuna.
And ironically the next topic is music, and this would be bang on topic.
Unfortunately I don't see any fire or ice, or any implication of fire and ice,
and your description doesn't make it any more on topic.

=====
From iacopo.mochi@tele2.it:
The image is really good. Unfortunately the "fire" theme is not present.
=====
From ian_c_thornton@hotmail.com:
A bit off-theme.  I bet you're kicking yourself now you know that the next
stills topic is "Music" ;-) Very much a case of being ahead of your time with
this one.  Excellent texture on the main fish surface and very realistic
looking ice.


=====
From limdaepl@gmx.de:
Hmm. Looks like you posted the wrong image? I was searching for the fire in your
image and i finally found it in your zip file. not sure how tho rate this now..
:-(

=====
From marlo.steed@uleth.ca:
This is a really nice image.  The concept of ice is strong but the concept of
fire is no where to be seen.  Perhaps it is there in a subtle way that I can't
see.
=====
From s.day@uel.ac.uk:
Nice image, should have saved it for the next round as it would have fit that
topic as well..

=====
From jgrimbert@free.fr:
Very nice! Ready for the next round.
the Fire aspect is too limited and a bit of a non-sense...

=====
From fcueto@rice.edu:
Nice image, but somewhat offtopic. Can't give full points.
=====
From ingo@freio.de:
Looks really great! Nevertheless, I can't give a high concept rating - it's, as
you stated yourself "a stretch as far as the topic goes". :(


=====
From file:
i like the refelections and stuff, and the piano key thing.! 


=====
From file:
Somewhat surreal but I like it. I bet you would have loved to know the topic of
the next still round in advance ;-)
Notable for originality