=====
From t.degroot@inter.nl.net:
Original interpretation of the theme, and visibly carefully built. Much attention has been paid to realistic structures and textures.
A few comments though. I would like to see more spray in this scene, partially hiding the lighthouse perhaps. The rain should lash under a more horizontal angle. And then, especially: I would like to see some rocks!!! Why is the ship sinking? There seems to be nothing there to further disaster. Sand banks? You should show something to make it more believable. Also, during a storm, a sailing ship does not ride with all its sails out. Only, maybe, some top sails. Try also to make the sea more dramatic! Sharper waves especially!

=====
From s.day@uel.ac.uk:
The lighthouse is excellent, the waves look good but I think there should be some splashing water around the lighthouse (very difficult to do though). Also, I think the ship does not look right and the flag looks too straight. I like the slight tilt to the camera angle.

=====
From diegocg@quipo.it:
This is a great image, but i'm not so sure about its link with the topic. 

=====
From billpragnell@hotmail.com:
The lighthouse is excellent. I think the sea is too reflective, though. In this kind of weather one would expect it to be much duller. Overall, though, very nice image - really moody.