=====
From chipr@niestu.com:
Good concept, but the images were a bit stiff and plastic.  Also, the movement
was too clearly "mathematical".  Nice modeling on the plane.

=====
From agage@mines.edu:
While the modeling is attractive, there are a few minor problems in this
animation.  First, the motion is very jerky, as you noted in your text file.
Next, the plane appears to drift sideways while approaching the runway.
Finally, there are two shadows cast by the plane as it lands, suggesting a
twin-sun world.

=====
From dick@buckosoft.com:
Nice models, nice lighting.  Could use better motion routines; the plane is
quite "static" no roll, pitch, yaw.  And it looks like its sliding sideways
(slipping) in its decent.

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
The biplane is very detailed and realistic.  I could almost hear it.
But what about that lighting?  Multiple shadows on the mountains?
Are there two suns in your sky?
Remember this: your eye tends to notice the thing which moves the fastest
within a scene.  Here, it is the shadows, not the plane.  So the multiple
shadows become very noticeable.  Try to find a way to minimize this.
Good landing and camera tracking.  Nice texture on the plane.
Good effort on the propeller but it is rotating rather slow.

=====
From nazrat@athabascau.ca:
Okay, just how many suns were there in the sky?  Count the shadows.
You can just about pinpoint the different sequences used to create the landing.
The switching from one vector to another was rather abrupt.  Any passenger
would
have bruises from the sudden shifts in directions.  Camera movement could have
been smoother as well.  Nice plane.
Would a partially transparent disk have been a better choice for a propeller?

=====
From bill@apocalypse.org:
This animation didn't play properly for me, it was choppy - perhaps it was too
fast for my hardware (P5-166)?


=====
From r@dmsst59.d.resnet.pitt.edu:
Nice biplane model, but the animation path is very linear and the propellers
need motion blur.


=====
From r@dial-up7.webbernet.net:
The plane is well made.  The pilot enhances it.  The trajectory seems too
vertical.  Those geometric mountains hurt the scene.


=====
From r@pm1-21.spectranet.ca:
Nice models, but the camera motion could use a little work and the planes flight
path is very linear.
Notable for modelling


=====
From r@auasc7-104.flash.net:
A nice model, but the tempo  is off.
Notable for modelling