===== From jake@snafu.de: I like your R2D2 ===== From bbowen@cswnet.com: You've put a lot of effort into the details here. I like that. The camera movement is smooth and not too dizzying. I'm not sure what the plot is exactly or how it fits with the theme but the 'bots are certainly busy doing something and I do like the way you look back at the entrance on the last shot to help orient the viewer. ===== From dick@buckosoft.com: There is a lot going on here. But it seems to have no purpose other than to show off lots of great technical skills. i.e. what is the story? ===== From AzChip@aol.com: One word: Wow! Excellent animation, excellent modelling. Great perspectives. To nitpick - the perspective motion was a bit awkward; from time to time the motion was way too fast, but for the most part was perfect. Loved the music; it was perfect for the context. ===== From bitdaf@tcainternet.com: Very good animation! ===== From Alain.Culos@bigfoot.com: Interesting concept. Seems like a lot of work. The entrance is what looks less realistic in the whole movie. Better clouds, some fog, snow and wind would have made for a terrific effect (Ok, I know I'm asking for a lot). ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: I sure like the exposition of all the different types of robots. Seeing how many I could recognize. But other than the thrill of this, there really isn't much story being told here. I wish the robots had a visible goal, a threat, a mission, or a surprise. The modeling and building structure are nice. As is the flowing camera movements and functional lighting. ===== From lou_bruce@yahoo.com: Very ambitious. Lots of things going on. Maybe could have used some "anticipation" in the scene changes. You knew that the director wanted you to see something but he didn't really give you an introduction. ===== From file: Good Job, but U should work a little bit more the trama and use less non-original models ===== From file: Notable for textures, composition