===== I envy your clouds. ===== background too blurry. ===== Good detail in plane. looks fairly realistic. No art content is my complaint. ===== This is very well proportioned (most constructed plaens aren't). Try doing a bit more in the background like some VistaPro mountains or height fields coming out of the clouds. Or even better, burning cities below! ===== I'm an aviation enthusiast, so that's just one more reason I like your rendering of the P-51. The only category I hit it heavily on was originality, but not for lack of effort or artistic ability. ===== Nice looking plane. This is a wonderful image, but not too much ray tracing going on here... (hence low TM score.) ===== Beautiful. I judge largely on realism and how inspirational the piece looks. This rendering reminds me of a professionally hand drawn image. As for inspirational, you're the money man! ===== This gives a very good impression of flight -- good viewpoint. ===== Nice image but I would give you more points if you did more rendering effects and less painting. ===== The aircraft is certainly nice, and I think the maps have worked well. But the background is very err.. unrealistic. I mean when was grass that colour? Here, I think using a backgroun image (as opposed to a background scene in 3D) has definitely not worked well. ===== The image is nice and so is the sentiment with the creators comments, but I am sick of plane images especially military ones. ===== I gather from your description that this was more 2D work than 3D. A remarkable result nevertheless. The P-51 needs to be much sharper in contrast to the background to make it stand out more. Where's the propeller? ===== Good use of color lacks orginality ===== good image but too much was drawn in a paint program. just about all the pieces of your image could have been rendered instead of drawn. also, planes are not very original ===== Much better than Crusader, Trevor, although the mustang seems a little sparse. ===== Very good sense of height. Texture on the plane looks a bit blurry.