=====
Good concept and great technically.

=====
Very good! THe wooden man IS simple, but effective, the leaves are brilliant. 
The halo effect in the clouds actually works (!) - this is good!

=====
Wonderful sky colors.

The sun effect is simple but dramatically improves the image.  Well Done!

=====
I loved the idea, and found it to be quite inspiring. Pay more attention to
finer details, the image appears a bit too plain.


=====
I like the sky. It's not distracting from the overall image, yet it's very
natural, especially the sun.


=====
good use of space
simple and pleasing figures
a bit more depth of field would have been nice



=====
I think the artist has said it all. The composition of the scene DOES work out,
and the model is a good reliable object. It is obvious that the leaves are all
the same, but on the other hand, the effect is not so bad, and doing each one
differently
would be hard. The sun has worked well, and so have the clouds. Yep, I like it!



=====
Well done.  I really enjoyed this piece.



=====

if nothing else very original!

=====
Excellent choice of colours - No over saturated bright colours that most
newusers gravitate towards.

=====
I like this image very much! 

=====
Rather good for being new to raytracing!  Better than my sad attempts, I have
to
admit.

=====
WONDERFUL CONCEPT LACKS DETAILS 

=====
very nice.  suggestions:  make one or two more leaves so that they don't all
look alike,  increase the contrast of the sky and clouds so they are more
visible.  good job!
dhoule@tng.net


=====

Nice minimalistic impression of concept.


=====
Beautiful colors, good composition, nice modelling, delightful concept.  Two
things threw me off--the veins on the leaves looked, ummm, off somehow, and
the attempt at motion blur at the wingtips failed.  One of the most original
and charming ideas of this round, though, and nice execution.  Good work!

=====
Very poetic! Nice colors and composition.