=====
Nice pastel colouring

=====
I value your restraint.  So many other images are overloaded with objects
and colors.  This one is simple and elegant.

=====
Nice image but nothing is really going on...

=====


I really like this. Suitable for framing.
=====
This image would have scored a lot higher if there were more seads.


=====
very nice, but for an extra ounce of reality, try making the stalk a little
bent... :)
Maybe a squished and stretched torus segment?...

=====
Had the background been more detailed, and there were more seeds, I would have
rated this image MUCH higher.  The concept is first rate.

=====
Lovely dreamy effect! Very appropiate for the topic. I've rarely seen such good
use of Vistapro

=====

Very original, nicely done, softness of "feathers" apparent. Took some technical
digging, too, from the sound of it.  Good job. Some people may fault you for
the "simplicity" of the scene, but I think it adds to its atmosphere.
=====
Image well balanced, but relies way too heavily on prepackaged material.

Nice concept.
=====
It is a pretty picture, but a little too dull. Try for more background "seeds" 
and the image would be a little more inspiring.


=====
The seeds are well rendered, but the scene is a little dull. Maybe if there were
more leaves or a more interesting ground, perhaps with trees and plants.


=====
Good concept.

=====


beautiful and simple, very nice
=====

This would have been nicer if there was a sharply detailed seed
floating in the viewer's near foreground.


=====
I think this is a lovely picture myself. I also think that if one of the
small background seeds was removed the picture would improve significantly.
Together
with the valley, the whole image is too symmetrical.
Computer rendering always seems to lend an air od unearthly perfection to an
image,
and together with a symmetrical composition the whole thing can end up looking
to smooth and mechanical and lifeless. I also recognised the vistapro landscape
instantly. I
don't rate it much as a landscape designer, myself. But this is a very good
image.
=====
Since most of the background is out of focus anyway it would have been better
to tighten the frame around the seeds with very sharp focusing on one with
corresponding increase in detailing of the model.



=====
How did you get the motion blur effect on the petals/wings ?

=====

nice, original
=====
Very peaceful image.

=====

A cool idea, but its so... empty, add some more seeds, and some more shadows
=====
I gave a moderately high score for technical merit, because I find that 
TrueSpace is a much more difficult and imprecise renderer to use than POV,
so the author deserves some credit there.  Concept and originality is OK,
because there are only one or two other seed images this time around.  I sure
hope these comments count for something, and that someone other than me
eventually ends up reading them.  I'd hate to think I was wasting my time.  :-)

=====
Quite a renderer!

=====
Beautiful.  Especially the seeds.

=====
SIMPLISTIC EXCELLEN ARTISTIC DESIGN WONDERFUL ORGINAL CONCEPT 
LACKS SOME TECHINCAL EXPERTISE

=====

easy does it.
=====
very nice but total image is too simple for the amoun of work you put into it. 
a closer view of the "seeds" would have filled more of the image space.  other
than that I liked it!


=====

Nice clean minimalistic image...

=====
Beautiful seed, nice background.  I love the feathery effect on the tassels.
They could stand to be curved, though.