=====
From chipr@niestu.com:
Cool lamps, excellent fruit, nice table.  The composition seems a bit
contrived, and the lens flare is a little bit overdone, especially for oil
lamp flames.  Very good use of color.

=====
From m-kolb@uiuc.edu:
Impressive. Perhaps a black atmosphere could be added to darken the scene
slightly and separate the foreground from the background. However, overall
I give this image high marks. Nice job!
- Michael J. Kolb

=====
From jay@map.com:
The only thing I've got a problem with in this scene is the lighting:  Way too
bright, in my opinion.  


=====
From seppo.halonen@hut.fi:
Oil lamps? Way too incandescent.. A more modest lens flare would have been
better.

=====
From cgallego@nordnet.fr:

There should be a "meritorious" rating... Just because you used Amiga/Real3d

http://home.nordnet.fr/~cgallego


=====
From richmiller@hotmail.com:
Very nice composition and colors!

=====
From tholal@bga.com:
The fruit looks great!

=====
From klynn@minn.net:

viva amiga!  
=====
From tiger@mgl.ca:
The only comment I'll make here is that the lens flare / glare is a bit too
emphasised.
The rest is very good :)


=====
From ucoakc00@mcl.ucsb.edu:
I like the star filter you have. I just hate it on this image. You have a
"quiet" image with rally "loud" lens flares. Why bother? A soft glow with the
lens reflections might have been nice, but for this image I would have omitted
lens flaring altogether. It makes your image almost annoying. My inner child
wants to cover your image with spray paint.


=====
From usmitc04@mcl.ucsb.edu:
it takes more than lens flare to make a good picture


=====
From danclegg@uniserve.com:
Coooooool! Verry pleasing to look at.
That's got to be some kind of volitile wax for that
size of lense flare.

=====
From rea@st-and.ac.uk:
Nicely modelled - shame about the lns-flare ;)   Seriously though, the image
is a bit light-flooded, which detracts from the nice modelling/texture work,
and the flares are *far* too bright.   Good otherwise.

=====
From mwhite@redshift.com:
It does not matter to me what render engine you are using.  The image looks 
wonderful.  

=====
From wyvern@u.washington.edu:
Gorgeous image.  Absolutely great, except for the lense flares.  You mention
photography - take a picture of a candle sometime, and see how the flare comes
out, even if overexposing the flame.  (Not even the sun itself can produce a 
flare that large).  Other than that, I love this one.  :)

=====
From jmills@stic.net:
Long live the Amiga!

=====
From amarok@geocities.com:
The fruits are great.

=====
From ptdawson@voicenet.com:
It's a nice scene! Don't worry about it being non-POV, it's actually rather
cool that you made it on an Amiga!

=====
From lpurple@netcom.com:
Very nice modelling, especially the green apple.

=====
From dick@buckosoft.com:
Excellent overall lighting.  I think you should have staggered the grain on the
wood
edging of the table.  (Its not possible to saw a piece of wood and line up the
grain
*that well*. :)  Bonus points for mentioning 'Amiga'.


From web_user@tonyv.aztec.co.za:
Nice apple.