=====
From sonya_roberts@geocities.com:
Do you ever get tired of receiving triple twenties?  I know I wouldn't *GRIN*
A great image...

=====
From jroy@internauts.ca:
Very well done.
Quite original, nice work

=====
From kazemir@pde.com:
Great image.  I like the composition and the detail.
Good pillars, although I think I would have spread them out farther.  The horses
are positioned well, but I find them a little "rounded", and perhaps they need
longer legs. They look shorter than the man.
=====
From bill.marrs@pureatria.com:
The horses are very good, also I liked the wheel in the foreground.  Great
sand.

=====
From jgoeson@msn.com:
Great concept, and a good picture.  I would have preferred to see more hand
drawing and less wireframe modelling and drafting, but again, the concept is
great.


=====
From jaime@ctav.es:
Hey! I've seen this film yesterday! Very Nice!
The Only But is the ground, seems a bit too soft.

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
Curious, this scene looks more like a model than a "full size" scene.  Is it the
lack of focal depth?  The lack of motion blur?  The bright plastic textures?  I
don't know.  First-class modelling.  Good use of the auxilliary light source.
What's the significance of "13"?

=====
From wozzeck@club-internet.fr:
Nice modelling and picture. Lighting is a bit overexposed, and makes horses look
metallic. Another detail: the leads are too linear... maybe a part of torus
would have helped.

=====
From MMandl@aol.com:
It was "stiff" artistically. Not up to your usual quality


=====
From dick@buckosoft.com:
You're really getting sophisticated.  I love the horse hooves and dead "13"
wheel.

=====
From bsieker@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de:
Somewhat artificial lighting ans somewhat plump horses.
Also parts of the horses' harness seems to either vanish inside the horse
or be completely inappropriate for pulling.

=====
From i_emackay@mountains.net.au:
Very good though I'm a little worried about the health of the horses. A lot of
hard work has gone into this image.

=====
From Martin.Magnusson.7121@student.uu.se:
Very good horse and pillar models! You  could
have done something more with the horse textures, though, they look a bit 
plastic. 

=====
From arcana@sinbad.net:
I like the concept. Some suggestions to make it a bit more "real" feeling:

Vary the positioning of the heads and legs on the horses. You went to all that
effort
of varying the textures on the horses, but most of them seem to have very
similar leg and 
head placements. Even at the distance you set the man at, I can see he has no
eyes.
Oh, and the spheres and geodomes at the top of the columns really don't fit
with
what I would expect in a Roman coluseum. I really like the extra touch of the
wheel
stuck in the mud.

=====
From ptdawson@voicenet.com:
Excellent scene, all it needs is a bit more dirt and grime.

=====
From peter@table76.demon.co.uk:
Not much chance of my having any constructive criticism on this one :-( .  I
merely gawp, remember to vote, and pass on....


=====
From web_user@flex058.dijkgraaf.wau.nl:
In one word: YOWZA! Unbelievable, great horses, very good texture! Some critics:
the wall is to perfect, I miss some mud or cracks or something. Right now they
seem close from being reflective. I like how the weel is buried in the sand,
but you could have inserted more objects - it's kind of lonely there.


=====
From web_user@px1.syd.aone.net.au:
very nice...but watch attention to detail.  What about sand flying up from the
hooves etc?
Notable for modelling


=====
From r@dialup83.webbernet.net>:
Nice idea.  Beautiful ground.  Horse faces need work.  I keep wanting to decrypt
the mosaic.
Notable for textures