===== From castlewrks@aol.com: This image suffers from the great detail in the figure and boat and the insignificance of the city behind. ===== From eallen@highway1.com: A very believable image of an unbelievable topic. ===== From trioker@wanadoo.fr: Sure it looks goods ! But does it quite fit the theme ? ===== From brendthess@aol.com: A very pretty image! The water is, perhaps, a bit too reflective. ===== From kistler@nevada.edu: Pretty picture, but... I don't see how it's unbelievable, other than the fact that you named it "Atlantis". Other than that I find it quite believable. ===== From nijman@nmtrix.com: Too bad you've used models from someone else, could have tried to build at least one model yourself. Great shot, great environmental settings, great camera angle, Keep sending in stuff ===== From gregj56590@aol.com: Superb blending of best features of several software pacakges. Nice feeling to image: I'd hang it on my wall! Only minor flaw: shouldn't there be open windows in the towers?? ===== From mar@physics.usyd.edu.au: Beautiful colours and good composition. The water looks a little flat though, and the buildings would look better with some variety in colour. Boat and womand are good. ===== From johnson@pharmacy.arizona.edu: A nice picture, thought the buildings seem a little repetitive (they're mostly just scaled.stretched copies of the same shape) Nicely done heightfield ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Remarkably intricate and powerfully imaginative. Seductive and majestic. Excellent. My only suggestions: move the figure slightly so that her head is not lost in the background, and of course, add a dock. ===== From autumn@sinbad.net: Even with the use of borrowed items, kudos for a well balanced scene with excellent lighting throughout. The only thing I may have worked on was the water surface. The waviness is great, but the surface is just too reflective. Oh, and if that is Atlantis, then that is our moon in the sky. If so, it needs a few craters, etc and may be looming a bit too large in the sky. Overall though, it's a great scene. ===== From jull43@ij.net: just another fantasy image ===== From sdevet@istar.ca: Single most beautiful pic in the contest! Deserves to win! Perfect! ===== From bobfranke@halcyon.com: Nice image but a little too crisp and clear for me. I would like to see a little haze in the atmosphere to give more depth. I like the use of the fractal for the landscape. ===== From file: I really like the composition of this image althought personally I would hav positioned the town a little to the left Notable for composition ===== From file: Notable for composition ===== From file: EXCELLENT. Notable for modelling, textures, lighting ===== From file: EXCELLENT!!! Great work on that water and sky. Notable for textures, lighting ===== From file: A good image, but Atlantis has been beat to death already. Notable for textures ===== From file: Whoa, I really like the lighting, gives this picture a really bright feeling. One minor gripe, between the chicks leg is something golden, doubt that's supposed to be there.