===== From cdsi26@bupers.navy.mil: Wow. Good thing I learned to read. This is a great scene. Very humorous and does connect to the catagory. Great Job.!!! ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: These guys looked more fun than horrifying. ===== From timk@jtse.com: Very funny. Nice contrast. Nice characters. Evil and menacing, yet cute. Kind of like Gremlins. Lots of nice extras. Very cool! ===== From schimmler@ica.uni-stuttgart.de: Good modelling! Cute Goblins but apart from their teeth not very frightning. ===== From ameede@madmac.com: Composition of the piece is excellent. The way you bring the viewer into your artwork to help personalize it is readily apparent. The fact that the tip of the sword, the eyes piercing at the viewer and the smiles on the figures verify this idea. You definitely prepared for this piece, and most important your own judgemental qualities allowed you to adjust the work as it developed. My only negative regarding this artwork is that the stone looks like it was hand rubbed with the skin oil that came off of those characters. ameede@madmac.com ===== From patrickd@netins.net: The goblins look good on the tops but the bottoms need more detail ===== From dwallace@lynx.dac.neu.edu: Warner Brothers horror... ===== From tina@ripco.com: Everything except the weapons seems modeled in toy plastic. Intentional? Your goblins are kinda cute. ===== From ericf@foothill.net: This is an image where a certain amount of cartoonish quality works, due to its humorous nature. The signs on the wall are a nice touch. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Those are wicked grins on the goblins. I like the 3d look of the sword coming right towards the viewer. ===== From peter@table76.demon.co.uk: I like this one :-) . If you had the fur ball in an include file, you could make the #include a comment when changing the door, and then you would not need to parse the fur ball. ===== From sjlen@ndirect.co.uk: Those goblins look asthough they really enjoy their work, and they're carrying weapons. The goblins are fantastic, the wall behind them looks a bit wet and the sword on the left doesn't look to be textured too well. I didn't read most of the text file, partly because you've written far too much and secondly because the image tells me a really good story which I didn't want to spoil by reading anyone else's oppinions on it. In future please keep your discription of how the scene was created a bit more brief.