===== From luisvaloyes@malditasea.zzn.com: the scene is simple but looks very cool, I just think the glass with water is a litlle small, but the butterflies are cool. ===== From BigTrav2001@chartermi.net: Artistically it looks okay, although uninspiring. However, the use of direct, no-modelling-involved image maps for the most important parts of your scene makes this technically even more uninspiring. ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: The butterflies look nice, but.... Most of the objects look good, but definitely a bit overly-simplistic. With some more work this could be a very nice scene, though. ===== From marlo.steed@home.com: Nicely done.Although the scene seems like the objects were just placed on the desk... what I am saying is that a bit of dirt and old crinkly paper and perhaps some other odds and ends would have helped with realism. ===== From marcelocarvajal@ieee.org: It looks like those images on the cover of ray-tracing books. Good light, shadows and reflection. The glass and water needs more work. Not too original. ===== From lrwii@janics.com: Nice use of image maps. The desk needs somthing maybe paper to go with the pencil. ===== From file: Not a bad scene, but too much use of imagemaps and too little modelling.