===== From nitro_glis@yahoo.com: it had to be hard working on such a profound image, ===== From philip.chan@home.com: I like the concept of the scene, and how you have created a realistic poster look. The hands in the texture for the plane look eerily as if they were pressing against some barrier, trying to escape. ===== From lrwii@joplin.com: The main lettering needs to stand out more for a poster. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: You seem to have put a fair amount of work into this, but it is my least-favorite image in the whole competition, sorry. ===== From tm-ray@consistent.org: Your list of slaughters (on all sides) does convey your desired point (anti-civilian slaughter on any side), but your "Now they're coming after our women and children" text does not. The choice of "they" and "our" was poor, and "women and children", which is a technically inaccurate and emotionally loaded propganda phrase, gives a "pro-US" feel that does not go the presence of US atrocities on the list. Propaganda posters are intended to get people riled up about the atrocities the other side has committed, so that they won't complain when your side commits atrocities in turn. They're very much "pro-our-side" and "anti-their-side". I think the format of a propaganda poster is fundamentally incompatible with your intended point, which is anti-atrocity-in-general.