=====
From higginsdj@bigpond.com:
Would have been better if the action was taken off the edge of the image

=====
From mookymaha@hotmail.com:
Very nicely done, plenty of detail.

=====
From philip.chan@home.com:
The wake and the fire look great.  The ships are detailed, but the texturing
doesn't look realistic.

=====
From djohnston@iname.com:
The water is too flat looking, as do the ship textures. The ships need to look
more worn down. The firing shots look good and the explosions, while a little
too yellow are nicely sized and placed for effect. Finding a closer camera
angle that still shows the proper scale fo the ships might also hepl improve
the image.

=====
From lrwii@joplin.com:
Nice todel effect. The wake could use more work.

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
Nice mood enhanced by dramatic lighting.  The ships 
look nice.  I think moving the moon away from the 
corner of the scene would improve the scene overall.

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
I like this one.  Nice ship models.  Sky seems too murky and I can see swirl 
marks as if it was an airbrushed image map.  Something about this image 
makes it look like small models in a tank of water.  Mabye it's the size of 
the ripples on the ocean surface.  Good lighting.

=====
From tm-ray@consistent.org:
Good detail on the ships.  Water looks unrealistically reflective,
however - the reflection of the moon is much brighter than the moon!