===== From staff@clickquicknow.com: The face looks too 'projected' on... but overall great. ===== From jouni@mikrobitti.fi: I like this. One problem though: It may not be logical, but to me this brings Africa into mind. The composition is good and the foreground well modeled, but the sea could use some work. ===== From marlo.steed@uleth.ca: Good image. Something about it looks like... well... not quite right can't quite explain why... perhaps it is the old face and clothes that don't seems to match. or perhaps it is the light that makes it seem like a 2D image. ===== From lrwii@joplin.com: Nice idea. The man looks more Afrigan than Asian. And every thing looks pasted on, with no real consistent shadows. ===== From chris_hormann@gmx.de: I think the concept is fairly good but there are some serious technical problems: The water is totally lacking reflection and although the sun seems to be shining there are no shadows. The composition looks nice. ===== From r@12-228-251-155.client.attbi.com: very nice models and textures... but there apears to be some very bad gamma cliping and it looks kinda grainy, I don't know TOO much bout blender, I know it does anialiasing but I'm not sure if you can adjust gamma from there. you can however adjust gamma in a paint prog. that is permited within the rules.